CHARLOTTESVILLE, VA (CVILLE RIGHT NOW) – Former University of Virginia football player Jahmal Edrine’s rape case continues to be dominated by disputes over evidence between the prosecution and defense. That continued during the latest pre-trial motion hearing Tuesday.

During the hearing at the Charlottesville Circuit Courthouse, Edrine’s defense attorneys, Rhonda Quagliana and Lawrence Woodward, said that the Commonwealth had not submitted the data dump of the complainant’s phone to the court, despite being previously ordered to do so.

Judge Claude Worrell ultimately asked Assistant Commonwealth Attorney Susan Baumgartner to submit the dump to him by noon Wednesday and told Edrine’s defense team he would provide them with the dump as well.

Quagliana later told Cville Right Now the case has been “uncharacteristically difficult” due to the discovery disputes, as well as the defense’s concerns over if the Commonwealth is fully adhering to the Brady rule, which requires the prosecution to disclose exculpatory evidence to the criminal defense, as set in the 1963 Supreme Court ruling of “Brady v. Maryland.”

Edrine’s latest appearance was a second pre-trial motion hearing, with court records indicating his jury trial is still set for Nov. 16-19. The majority of Tuesday’s hearing took place behind closed doors due to “The Rape Shield Laws” in Virginia’s code, which restricts the admission of evidence or cross-examination of the complaining witness’ sexual history.

Edrine was arrested on Feb. 5 on charges of rape and abduction stemming from a Aug. 24 incident. He is accused of ignoring a woman’s request that he not ejaculate insider her after what began as a consensual sexual encounter.

Edrine was released on a $25,000 bond in February on the conditions that he wear an ankle monitor, have no unrelated women in his apartment and have no contact with his accuser.

During his bond hearing, Baumgartner and Quagliana both pointed to different text conversations recovered from Edrine’s phone between him and the woman to craft their respective arguments, indicating the logs will likely play a major role in the trial.

Quagliana argued the complainant denied she had been raped in text messages and sought a rape kit in her home state of Florida solely because she was concerned about potential STDs and pregnancy.

During the February bond hearing, Baumgartner contended that text messages between Edrine and his accuser establish his guilt.

“’I told you ‘No’ twice, three times actually,’” Baumgartner said then, reading a text. Edrine’s accuser also texted that he did not know what the word “No” meant. The complainant also wrote to Edrine that, “You sending money doesn’t undo what you did.”

Edrine played one season as a wide receiver at UVA after spending two years at Purdue and two at Florida Atlantic. He caught 46 passes for 564 yards and a touchdown for the Cavaliers in 2025.